Do you know someone who could help? Thank you!
Esc to close
Esc to close
Key document for my case / court hearing 24 March
Esc to close
Esc to close
January 2023
Moved to France from New York
"Creator of Enterprise / Passport Talent" visa
Esc to close
Esc to close
Esc to close
Esc to close
Esc to close
Esc to close
1. Moving to France. Attempts to register LLC (video)
Esc to close
Why did I move to France from New York?
- Read NYT article on "La French Tech" - it seemed cool.
- Always liked France - visited often.
- Wanted to establish a European "base" for my startup in Paris.
Key aspects of my venture:
- Business model: "Masterclass meets 'collective Dr. House'"
- AI-driven worldwide in 10+ languages.
- No need for grants or state support.
- Rented long-term apartment.
- Immediately applied for LLC online.
- Started business development work.
But nothing was possible without a physical Carte de Séjour (Residence Card) in my hand. No French banks or EURL (LLC) registrants accepted an e-version!
October 2023
Waiting 10 months for Carte de Séjour.
Silence from all officials.
Esc to close
Esc to close
Esc to close
2. Video for Jean-Noël Barrot / asking for help
Esc to close
3. Video for Bruno Le Maire / asking for help
Esc to close
10 months in France
Nothing is possible in France without a printed Carte de Séjour.
- Visa portal enquiries (Portail des Étrangers) resulted in auto-replies: "You must wait".
- Police prefecture does NOT let in without an appointment letter (it never arrived).
Started to contact "La French Tech" / Ministry of "Digital Affairs" and Economics:
- Clara Chappaz (La French Tech director)
- Jean-Noël Barrot (3 attempts)
- Bruno Le Maire (3 attempts)
I have never received a reply from anyone.
January 2024
1 year in France: No legal entity,
No bank account, No health insurance.
4. Video for President Macron / asking for help
Esc to close
Esc to close
Esc to close
Esc to close
12 months in France
A letter and video for President Macron (X, LinkedIn):
- Sent a letter via Élysée Palace "Contact the President" web form on 29 December 2023.
- Received a reply on 06 February 2024: "Your letter was forwarded to the right department at the Ministry of the Interior."
I also wrote to many members of cabinets for:
- 'Digital Minister' (Marina Ferrari, who took over from Jean-Noël Barrot),
- Minister of Economics (Bruno Le Maire) and
- President Macron's cabinet (Alexis Kohler, Rodrigue Furcy)
None of the emails bounced back.
I've never received any replies.
April 2024
Card printed after 15 months in France.
My 92 y.o. mother's visa expired.
5. Situation update March 2024 (and my mother's case)
Esc to close
6. (video) Residence card (Carte de Séjour) printed 15 months after moving to France.
Esc to close
7. (video) "Creator of Enterprise" is NOT allowed to register an enterprise in France due to French government regulations (Qonto representative call).
8. "We will not open a bank account for you" - a voicemail from the French bank (SocGen)
15 months in France
Someone got me a Carte de Séjour appointment.
- Residence card was printed 15 months after I arrived France.
- "Residence permit not available" remained in the web portal for at ~2 months AFTER the card was in my hands (!)
- I've never received an official notification to pick up the card.
But !!! "Passport Talent" visa holder is NOT allowed to register a legal entity in France!
- Even with my Carte de Séjour in hand, I could not get a EURL (LLC) registered in France.
- Qonto, a leading French business services provider, explained that French government regulations prohibited opening legal entities for Passeport Talent holders.
- <- Listen to the conversation with a Qonto representative after my online EURL application was rejected.
Banks also refused to open an account for me.
- Listen to a voicemail from Société Générale bank representative saying they will not open a personal (and business) bank account.
- I went to several banks - same result. And without a French RIB I cannot open an account online.
- But I need a EURL (LLC) legal entity and a business bank account first!
January 2025
Renewal time for my "Passeport Talent"
Still no LLC, no bank account, no health insurance.
9. Video for President Macron (December 2024). Posted on X, LinkedIn.
Esc to close
Esc to close
Esc to close
01 August: Still awaiting visa renewal (7 months)
24 months in France
If "Passport Talent" is useless in France, maybe "just Passport"? ;)
- I appealed to President Macron again (X, LinkedIn, emails to Cabinet members)
- I submitted my "Passport Talent" visa renewal application in January 2025.
September 2025
04 September: Visa renewal rejected.
Deportation Order (OQTF) issued.
Reason for refusal: "You did not register an LLC"!
~3 years in France
Visa renewal rejection letter cites "lack of legal entity opening" as a reason for rejection. But:
- I have made extraordinary efforts to open a legal entity in France since I arrived 33 months ago.
- 15 months of a 24-month validity of my "Passport Talent" were spent waiting for a printed card.
- 8 more months were spent waiting for a renewal, during which legal entity registration attempts were not possible.
01 October 2025
2 days before “deportation” deadline
my lawyer discovered a key problem:
Esc to close
34 months in France
- In January 2024 "Passeport Talent" words were REMOVED from the 'passeport talent' program's name, thus making Residency Cards with "Passeport Talent" words on them invalid.
This change of words was CRITICAL: Residence cards (carte de séjour) with words “Passport Talent” NO LONGER served their purpose (to open legal entity). - I received my card 3 months after the law was changed - in April 2024 (after 15 months wait).
But my card had an OLD wording ("Passeport Talent") - This is exactly what representative of QONTO told me (a French accounting and legal entity registration platform) : "Your “Passeport Talent” is no longer accepted by the French government to register a legal entity in France”. See transcript and audio on the left side.
That is why with an "old type" of Carte de séjour with "Passport Talent" words I was never able to register a legal entity (EURL) in France.
- Then my renewal was rejected and I got “OQTF” - a demand to leave France in 30 days. This deadline expires on 03 October.
- Discovery of root cause of refusal to register my LLC does NOT mean that my "deportation order" will be rescinded, despite letters of support from La French Tech and Assamblée Nationale deputies.
- Because... I don't know why!
10 October 2025
Court Hearing #1
Urgent Deportation Appeal
Letter from top French business registration service confirms that my Residency Permit...
...is not acceptable for French LLC (EURL) registration due to outdated wording.
36 months in France
The judge REJECTED on 13 October my appeal for urgent reversal of deportation and reinstatement of my entrepreneur legal status.
- Next hearing on the merits of my appeal is scheduled on 24 March 2026.
- Until that time, I remain in an illegal status in France.
- On 10 October 2025 I had a hearing at the Administrative Court of Paris. I filed for urgent dismissal of my deportation order (“OQTF”).
The French State (Paris Police Prefecture) sent a grey-haired lawyer who passionately argued against me for 30 minutes in front of the judge! - It looked just like in the movies - a fiery speech, flailing lawyer’s robes, and hand waiving, with pointing to me and my old mother sitting on a bench.
Paris Police Prefecture's lawyer argued that:
(1) I had not worked on my venture since I came to France,
(2) I have no stable housing and no income, and
(3) I have no “friendly relations”, “social activities", and “integration into French society”.
All that are blatant lies:
(1) My e-health venture is my full-time activity, for years.
(2) I have been renting the same flat in Paris for ~3 years (lease available)
(3) I have been a member of HBS Club of France, Harvard Club of France, and attended ~100 social and business events in Paris, ~30 art exhibitions, and I have developed hundreds of social and business contacts in France since my arrival in Paris in 2023. - QONTO issued me a letter confirming that my Residency Card (Carte de séjour) with words “Passeport Talent” was NO LONGER accepted by the French authorities for legal entity registration.
QONTO is a top French legal entity registration and business management firm for entrepreneurs.
See letter in French and English translation on the other side of a timeline arrow.
24 March 2026
Court Hearing #2
Deportation Appeal
KEY DOCUMENT TO READ
DOCUMENT CLÉ À LIRE
3 years in France
PUBLIC court hearing will be on the "substance" of my appeal against Deportation Order and Visa Renewal
- TRIBUNAL ADMINISTRATIF DE PARIS
- 24 March, 09:30 AM
- Salle René Chapus, 7 rue de Jouy, Paris.
Come to the court hearing and support me!
Do you know someone who could help? Thank you!
(thumbnail image below)